Даёт ли психолог советы?

38epxov7t1q9nmm2
the

If laziness to read, the spoiler – giving, if appropriate.

— — —

Now the details.

Have an idea of what a real (well, what else can you go?) psychologist and psychotherapist does not give advice. If you give – so, no, he's not real, is a charlatan, which is necessary to drive the filthy broom. The psychologist should help to recognize the problem, to take responsibility and to understand the situation.

So? Sort of.

the Precise meaning of the word “tip”. In the ordinary sense advice – it is the wish of the result, and so want person, usually without specific instructions, how to do it. In our culture they often give without asking, paying attention, and participation in the life of the interlocutor. About the same as an expression of love, forcing us to eat everything on the plate. 

now imagine a normal situation – the person rolls over the anxiety so unbearable to live. Gets the sufferer to a specialist, and that:

— Well, you could use a positive thinking. And Yes, it is advisable to cease worrying.

— But how the hell how to do it? I want it to stop, but I can't…

— Take responsibility for the state. Do you have time to “grow psychologically" and decide to stop worrying…

— — —

This hypothetical scene is not so incredible. First, many people think that psychologists and work – then why go to them? Secondly, unfortunately, some of the colleagues are really works well. Alas.

Therefore, adequate staff with these tips do not give — it doesn't make sense. The one who does that (except that he works in an institution where there are patient flow), not reputed to be a highly…

and Another thing – specific recommendations when the expert understands the problem and what the client is willing to comply with them. Then the psychologist gives a clear and understandable instruction – all possible in the moment of action that will change the situation. «And now, when we finish the consultation, the first thing you're going to the stationery, buy the notebook, and you'll note the date, time, circumstances, and exactly what I think when worry… next week will come the next consultation will be entry we will discuss them and take the next step”. 

If you use a more General definition of “tip – guidance, instruction, suggestion, how to proceed”, then Yes, it's advice. However, the other quality. These recommendations I prefer to not name the Council, because this word has acquired a negative connotation, and homework. But the point – an indication of how to proceed and what exactly to do – the same. 

Yes, there are other situations. “Tell me to leave work/to divorce/to say at last, Mama… or not?” on one side, not the business expert to decide how to live. On the other – someone has to provoke a definitive response to the man began to search for arguments for or against – and clarification of what to choose. 

most Importantly – to understand that someone in which situations recommend or prescribe, and when to avoid a specific answer. Quite often the client comes when the resources are not many, and a clear concrete task – this is exactly what you need.

So when appropriate, to competent specialist advice. And when inappropriate – not.

P. S. Need some advice? Look here




!